| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1t. | 10 | S86 | M26 | Jake Bates | Detroit Lions | Commish Jeff |
| 1t. | 10 | S69 | M23 | Jason Myers | Seattle Seahawks | Pettigrew95 |
| 1t. | 10 | S67 | M23 | Randy Bullock | Tennessee Titans | MrRoclo |
| 1t. | 10 | S65 | M22 | Tristan Vizcaino | Los Angeles Chargers | MrRoclo |
| 1t. | 10 | S62 | M22 | Sam Ficken | Tennessee Titans | DoubleD187 |
| 1t. | 10 | S16 | M11 | Nick Folk | New York Jets | Commish Jeff |
| 1t. | 10 | S02 | M04 | Josh Brown | Seattle Seahawks | Rwt1983 |
| 9t. | 9 | S86 | M26 | Andres Borregales | New England Patriots | Bengalsonly_7 |
| 9t. | 9 | S85 | M26 | Jake Bates | Detroit Lions | Commish Jeff |
| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | 95 | S77 | M25 | Eddy Pineiro | Carolina Panthers | Devcode1523 |
| 3. | 92 | S65 | M22 | Chase McLaughlin | Green Bay Packers | MackDaddy |
| 4t. | 91 | S82 | M26 | Harrison Butker | Kansas City Chiefs | Bubbaduran07 |
| 4t. | 91 | S65 | M22 | Tucker McCann | Cleveland Browns | Canesbucs1 |
| 4t. | 91 | S64 | M22 | Matt Haack | Las Vegas Raiders | Number1FanofEA |
| 7. | 90 | S66 | M22 | Rodrigo Blankenship | Indianapolis Colts | Boobie_MTZ7 |
| 8. | 89 | S75 | M24 | Devin Glenn | Carolina Panthers | Betroit |
| 9. | 88 | S17 | M11 | Robbie Gould | Chicago Bears | MJSween2003 |
| 10. | 86 | S67 | M23 | Robbie Gould | San Francisco 49ers | Betroit |
