| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2t. | 7 | S75 | M24 | Jake Moody | San Francisco 49ers | Commish Jeff |
| 2t. | 7 | S70 | M23 | Matthew Wright | Dallas Cowboys | Estrada |
| 2t. | 7 | S69 | M23 | Oscar Davis | Carolina Panthers | Bengalsonly_7 |
| 2t. | 7 | S68 | M23 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | Mindenplaya |
| 6t. | 6 | S85 | M26 | Harrison Mevis | New York Giants | BuffaloBill |
| 6t. | 6 | S84 | M26 | Tyler Bass | Buffalo Bills | Bhicks14 |
| 6t. | 6 | S83 | M26 | Cam Little | Jacksonville Jaguars | BigDre245 |
| 6t. | 6 | S80 | M25 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | Mindenplaya |
| 6t. | 6 | S77 | M25 | Daniel Carlson | Las Vegas Raiders | Commish Jeff |
| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | 47 | S39 | M17 | Eric Vinatieri | New Orleans Saints | DoubleD187 |
| 3. | 45 | S45 | M18 | Matt Prater | Atlanta Falcons | BigReg |
| 4t. | 44 | S84 | M26 | Tyler Loop | Baltimore Ravens | MMXCalibur |
| 4t. | 44 | S74 | M24 | Justin Tucker | Baltimore Ravens | Mack |
| 6t. | 42 | S73 | M24 | Wil Lutz | New Orleans Saints | Boobie_MTZ7 |
| 6t. | 42 | S50 | M19 | Randy Bullock | Cleveland Browns | Pettigrew95 |
| 8t. | 41 | S80 | M25 | Jason Sanders | San Francisco 49ers | MMXCalibur |
| 8t. | 41 | S55 | M20 | Jason Sanders | Miami Dolphins | KnightNoles |
| 10. | 40 | S79 | M25 | Brandon Aubrey | Dallas Cowboys | Coach QKP35 |
