| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2t. | 6 | S65 | M22 | Jason Verrett | Buffalo Bills | BuffaloBill |
| 2t. | 6 | S55 | M20 | Taylor Mayberry | Cleveland Browns | MackDaddy |
| 2t. | 6 | S55 | M20 | Byron Jones | Dallas Cowboys | RobPowers |
| 2t. | 6 | S55 | M20 | Marshon Lattimore | New Orleans Saints | Kalikarpenter |
| 2t. | 6 | S51 | M20 | Ronald Darby | Philadelphia Eagles | Coach QKP35 |
| 7t. | 5 | S86 | M26 | Tyrone Ware | Green Bay Packers | Latinyank77478 |
| 7t. | 5 | S84 | M26 | Denzel Ward | Cleveland Browns | Domi_TSX |
| 7t. | 5 | S82 | M26 | Trevon Diggs | Dallas Cowboys | Coach QC |
| 7t. | 5 | S71 | M23 | Chad Muma | Detroit Lions | Coach QKP35 |
| # | Record | Season | Edition | Player | Team | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | 31 | S08 | M07 | Rashean Mathis | Jacksonville Jaguars | Canesbucs1 |
| 3. | 27 | S61 | M21 | Kenneth Murray Jr. | Los Angeles Chargers | MackDaddy |
| 4. | 25 | S55 | M20 | Adrian Amos Jr. | San Francisco 49ers | Enzo |
| 5t. | 24 | S60 | M21 | Devin White | New York Jets | Bubbaduran07 |
| 5t. | 24 | S24 | M13 | Darrelle Revis | New York Jets | Latinyank77478 |
| 5t. | 24 | S18 | M11 | Nnamdi Asomugha | Oakland Raiders | IGotASxyWife |
| 8t. | 23 | S60 | M21 | Denzel Ward | Cleveland Browns | MrWitness36 |
| 8t. | 23 | S24 | M13 | Antonio Cromartie | New York Jets | Latinyank77478 |
| 10. | 23 | S60 | M21 | Greedy Williams | Cleveland Browns | MrWitness36 |
